The
always exciting task of weeding through the internet to find valuable
and credible information is becoming harder everyday because of the
massive amounts of information we share. I think that I am a pretty good
“information detective”, aka searcher. I like to have a challenge of
trying to find something on the internet because I am certain it is all
there. In the past there are things that others can’t find and even
though I will spend an hour searching I feel like I can find if it is
there. As a teacher and a prospective teacher librarian it is important
to be able to curate resources to help my students stay streamlined
during different projects and research. I like the beginning of, Joyce
Valenza’s article,
(http://www.schoollibrarymonthly.com/articles/Valenza2012-v29n1p20.html)
where she says “Digital curators can prevent oversaturation by
filtering and diverting the onslaught and by directing what is worth
sharing into more gentle and continuous streams..” This is exactly where
I get my motivation to curate for students. It makes sure they are not
overwhelmed by fluff when looking for meaningful support. The other
quote I like from the same source is, “Librarians can synchronize
communities.” This is a huge statement and so important to notice, a
curator could provide a whole community the information they need to
accomplish a project and providing them with the same information can
cause them to all be on the same page. The same information causes a
harmonious mesh of knowledge amongst different people!? WOW!
Absolutely, I believe this to be true because any group of people who
monitor the same news outlet, will begin to have the same beliefs and
the same underlying opinions as the others who monitor that outlet. If
librarians are curating for a school community wouldn’t it be awesome if
all of the information that was disseminated was homogenous? Then all
of the faculty would cruise through different articles or resources and
share with their peers causing a jigsaw mix of information that all
correlates.
I almost feel as though the search for information on the internet is
a game. A hide and seek at times that becomes frustrating which makes
it even more intense for me to find it. We are not all a part of the
Google Generation. There are still people who do not know how to ask
questions to Google to help be more efficient in their jobs. For
instance, over half of my students do not realize they can talk to their
phone and ask google very specific questions, to which they will be
provided an answer. I use Google for timers, clocks, and sometimes math
problems (I am not very good at math). One of the largest commonalities
between my students and I, is that we are very dependent on Google. Most
people have seen the question “who did we ask before Google?” I know
the answer because I have been around long enough to see the transition
into the Google age. Teachers, books, magazines, and people were our
outlet for useless trivia and important questions. The beauty of
curation is that it allows you to create a filter bubble in a sense. It
provides parameters for other users and keeps them within a certain set
of boundaries. This takes me back to the “synchronizes communities”
statement. This curation when shared with a community allows the users
to roam within the safe haven that has been created. Thus, creating a
common knowledge base on a certain topic to which all would become
familiar with just by reading, and talking with one another about the
subject. On Beth’s Blog
(http://www.bethkanter.org/content-curation-101/#sthash.ja79VSw2.dpuf )
she tells us,”content curator cherry picks the best content that is
important and relevant to share with their community.” This is the
creation of a type of filter bubble.
I think you have some interesting points in your discussion. As a media specialist, we are responsible for curating content for our schools. How do we make sure that we aren't putting students into our own personal filter bubble? I know it is sometimes difficult to separate our person beliefs totally from the content we are using. This is definitely a challenge for media specialists. Our school is always filtering things that they feel might be inappropriate for our students. This filter blocks out all social media as well as YouTube. I can see the reasoning, but it makes it hard to use those things in the classroom since they are filtered. I am also addicted to using Google. I find myself very frustrated when I am using another computer that has the default search set to Yahoo or Bing. I can't ever seem to find what I am looking for on those search engines.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading Richard's blog post and your reply I have to admit, I had not thought about the filter bubble in the same way you had Amanda! We definitely don't want to accidentally and subconsciously put our students inside our own filter bubble. It could be easily done though, without us even knowing it! Our school also blocks a lot of websites that could be useful. It's so aggravating when you find an awesome video clip at home only to get to the school and realize it's blocked! I too am also a Google junkie. I agree with what you said about not liking Bing or Yahoo. Whenever I am on a computer that has a search engine other Google, I find myself going straight to google.com!
DeleteGoogle! I love it and prefer it over any other search engine. Just like Amanda mentioned, I too am unable to find information that I am looking for when using other search engines.
ReplyDelete(As a side note, since we are all google users: Have you ever thought, "Would it not be cool to be the person who gets to design the Google logo everyday?" I've thought this many of times and am slightly envious of whoever has the job! Maybe I should "google it" and find out. Ha!)
I like the way you discussed the filter bubble in the school aspect. These days we do count on the technology and media specialists to keep us filtered on the school network. This is a huge help for teachers. Could you imagine what it would be like if it wasn't filtered? Oh my!
"Librarians can synchronize a community" is a very important statement. I think that most of the time teachers don't give enough credit to the media specialist for what they do as far as synchronizing a community. Our media specialist has done a good job with this at my school, however, I think that myself and many more haven't stopped to think how did this get all linked together?
I also agree with the School Library Monthly article when it said, "We need curators more than ever as we connect complex text to the Common Core State Standards, and as we maximize the potential of emerging curation platforms..."
One of the most convincing notions of the internet is that all the information is there! This is what makes us all apart of the Google Generation.
ReplyDeleteStudents now do not ask many questions in class and have a hard time holding a discussion about topics covered in class. I think they also have a social filter bubble. I've noticed that during lecture if I incorporate some type of media I may get more discussion from the students than normal but it is still limited. If I allow them any free time I can here them discussing as groups about a video that has gone viral on the internet. They have a lot more to say about the video that has over a million views than they do about a video or clip I showed on our current classroom topic. I think curators in the classroom setting would help solve this issue and draw the students into more topics of classroom content.